Plastics

Should ACTA have Plastic kits

  • Replace All metals with plastics

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Replace all large kits with Plastics

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Replace all small kits with plastics

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
mthomason said:
A good way to make it economical is to start with a single sprue with one or two common ships from each race, and include two or three in every boxed set as well as a seperate "reinforcements" box, that way when someone buys the game theres enough ships for a few simple starter battles, and they can be shared out or swapped with other players. You've also then got a boxed game that can go into more mainstream stores to get people interested in the game, maybe even produce a "dumbed down" version with the same minis in the same way GW used to do stuff with MB games. Include a little flyer in each box and get the players hooked and migrate 'em to the full version of the game, they get to practice painting their first ships with plastics plus it makes the plastics available to everyone else who wants them without replacing the existing metal range.

Ohhh.. I like it. Though I hope that the continue to produce metal minis as well as plastic. I'm rather found of metal and wouldn't want half my fleet ending up in plastic.
 
Sidewinder: I use several different master making methods, most commonly
I will find a size I want to make, locate appropriate size metal washers at the local hardware store, I then silver solder two washers together for extra thickness and heft in the as cast base. I then sculpt whatever detail and final shape I want into the master using Magicsculpt a two part epoxy product out of Carmichael, California, USA.
This product is far superior to green stuff in all catagories :smoother, can be sculpted thinner cures literally rock hard, can be drilled sanded etc. once cured. The most important quality is that Magicsculpt handles the extended heat of the mold vulcanizing process without breaking down.
Magicsculpt is available in quantities from a small test sample for $5.ooUSD to one hundred pound containers.
Then you must have the proper mold making and casting tools as well as the knowledge of working with them and casting molten metal alloy at 600-750 degrees F. It is a lot of fun but not the safest aspect of the hobby.
Another process involves the use of high temperature resistant RTV which allows for direct casting when cured byut doesn't involve high temperature vulcanizing,
Sorry for such a lengthy reply, Hope it helps. :twisted: :twisted:
 
for those interested, those proces I quoted were circia 1997...I'm sure they're much more now (remembers a $50 marine tactical squad on display...!!!!)

Chern
 
One thing I've heard about plastic molds as opposed to metal is that while the metal is conciderably cheaper to produce they also last only a fraction of the life of a mold for plastics...Case in point, the AoG molds are already falling apart...
Basically the economics came down to demand in that the higher up front cost, longer life span, and cheaper materials mean that plastics are only economical for long term, high volume sales...

As for conversion, yes you can make conversions with metal minis but they are generally much harder to do...Heck, I've got the tools to do plastic and even "green stuff" conversions but nothing to cut cleanly through metal...

And incidentally a lot of GW plastics are expensive because they are including the up front cost in the price rather then spacing it out some...And then there are others which are simply priced based on the importance of the model in game terms (characters models cost more then an almost identical squad leader which cost more in turn then the basic trooper)...That's one thing that's always bugged me about GW pricing...No more or less effort went into designing it and they are almost identical in production costs...

Sorry, the last part was a little rantish...
I didn't vote because the option I would choose would be "only the most common models for each fleet" which includes fighters and usually a couple of ships (probably 1 Patrol, 1 Raid/Skirmish, 1 Battle)...
 
some models might take to plastic much better. I know the hermes would be a better model if plastic - the oversize fins on the back are very difficult to work in metal.
Chern
 
deathlynx said:
And incidentally a lot of GW plastics are expensive because they are including the up front cost in the price rather then spacing it out some...And then there are others which are simply priced based on the importance of the model in game terms (characters models cost more then an almost identical squad leader which cost more in turn then the basic trooper)...That's one thing that's always bugged me about GW pricing...No more or less effort went into designing it and they are almost identical in production costs...

Heh. I bought an Assassin back when they were ridiculously expensive. YOu paid twice as much for a 1 or 2 piece assassin as opposed to a squad leader that was a multi-part model with a sprue of plastic add-ons...

Seriously, I'd love to see ACTA plastics, even if they're a weird chunk of the product line. Of course, I've also argued for a true '2nd edition' at some point in the future. Maybe the 2nd edition box set could be a mix of the new 'starter set' featuring two armies, but with full rules and a selection of plastic minis.

I wouldn't complain about a few stealth resculpts being added in... Like the wonderful Hyperion/Avenger hybrid I've seen posted here.

And, of course fighters... And I just managed to get a shipment of Thunderbolts and Starfuries in (Insert joke about LBH having them all here), but I still could sue some Nials and that's not counting the fleets I'd like to build. :)
 
Ok Fighters and Capital Ships like the Victory and the super carrier Persidon should be plastic of something lighter so it is easyer to handle
 
Shadow Queen said:
Ok Fighters and Capital Ships like the Victory and the super carrier Persidon should be plastic of something lighter so it is easyer to handle

Nooooo!!!! You can't make the VCD a lightweight!!!!

LBH
 
I'd think, that an ACTA basis box with some miniatures included would be a very good idea. So that you get used how it feels to play with minis right from the start. I would have loved to get some of the basics ships as minis in the box.
 
lastbesthope said:
Shadow Queen said:
Ok Fighters and Capital Ships like the Victory and the super carrier Persidon should be plastic of something lighter so it is easyer to handle

Nooooo!!!! You can't make the VCD a lightweight!!!!

LBH

Mine fell and landed on my big toe that has an ingrowing nail ...wouldnt it be nice if LBH could have the pain
 
lastbesthope said:
Shadow Queen said:
Ok Fighters and Capital Ships like the Victory and the super carrier Persidon should be plastic of something lighter so it is easyer to handle

Nooooo!!!! You can't make the VCD a lightweight!!!!

LBH

It would save your shelves from collapsing under the weight of unassembled metal. :D
 
Greg Smith said:
lastbesthope said:
Shadow Queen said:
Ok Fighters and Capital Ships like the Victory and the super carrier Persidon should be plastic of something lighter so it is easyer to handle

Nooooo!!!! You can't make the VCD a lightweight!!!!

LBH

It would save your shelves from collapsing under the weight of unassembled metal. :D

And the assembled unpainted metal :D

Yes folks, it's "lets gang up on LBH" day!
 
OK, follow up question:

Would people want plastics to begin a process of 'size normalization' with effort expended to bring sizes more in line? I.E. more accurate scale between capital ships. (Although I think fighters would still be oversized unless they were made miniscule.)
 
The Honorable former Governor of Minnessota Jesse Ventura, "Predator."

Chern
:wink:

and no I haven't forgotten Jeopardy...
 
Chernobyl said:
The Honorable former Governor of Minnessota Jesse Ventura, "Predator."

Chern
:wink:

and no I haven't forgotten Jeopardy...

I don't remember that line, I do remember the classic "I ain't got time to bleed!" :lol:
 
Back
Top