ross said:
far-trader said:
"Hey yeah, you just WEAR Battle Dress as this proves, so why do I need it as a skill in Traveller?"
That is a completely specious argument.
How so?
ross said:
I can pick up a knife, but I can't whittle a reclining buddha.
Well, if you want a specious argument there's one
Who says whittling isn't a skill? Yes anyone can pick up a knife but some shouldn't. And few will have the skill to carve a buddha with it even if skilled in some other application with a knife, like combat.
ross said:
It even states in the rules that skill checks are not for normal use.
Perhaps I wasn't clear, I haven't looked at the rules, I was just hoping to make a point in advance of the usual tired arguments about BD skill. Missed again I guess.
So, what exactly is "normal" use for BD? Walking? No skill needed unless you never learned to walk in the first place. So far so good, we're on the same page there. No skill needed and no skill check required.
What then is "abnormal" use of BD? Tightrope Walking? No, that wouldn't be BD skill, that'd be some Acrobatic skill.
Really, what does BD skill cover then? Is there one clear example? Something that isn't already covered by some other skill?
All I'm saying is that a suit of neuro receptor driven armor is going to react to the normal body inputs. There will be no skill required to use it. Any skill requirement and check will be dependent on what you do with it.
And again, to be sure, I've not had a chance to look at the rules so I have no idea what the treatment of BD is in them.