Clovenhoof
Mongoose
I read an article to the same effect about 8 years ago, and I more or less scanned this one. Didn't convince me then, doesn't convince me now, won't convince me in the next eight years either.
What can a level 9 character do that is so "superhuman"?
Sticking to Jump as an example for skills: Jump 12 ranks plus 2 or 3 ability mod - so with "Take 10" he can reliably jump maybe 25 feet. World Record is about 30 feet. And even if he rolls a 20 and makes a 35 ft jump, and crunching the numbers maybe up to 40' - so what? That's just a sign that D20 is. not. a. simulation. of. the. real. world. If it was, any olympic athlete would not reliably jump, say, 27 to 30 ft, but anywhere between 10 and 30 feet, and that is clearly not the case.
The system just doesn't WORK that way. You CANNOT simulate real world physics with D20. It's pointless. If you want to do that, and have PCs that can do no more, no less than real world persons, take a system like Gurps or suchlike. Really.
Trying to nerf a D20 game, whether Conan or not, to a "only what you can do in real life" level is TOTALLY beside the point of a heroic fantasy game.
What can a level 9 character do that is so "superhuman"?
Sticking to Jump as an example for skills: Jump 12 ranks plus 2 or 3 ability mod - so with "Take 10" he can reliably jump maybe 25 feet. World Record is about 30 feet. And even if he rolls a 20 and makes a 35 ft jump, and crunching the numbers maybe up to 40' - so what? That's just a sign that D20 is. not. a. simulation. of. the. real. world. If it was, any olympic athlete would not reliably jump, say, 27 to 30 ft, but anywhere between 10 and 30 feet, and that is clearly not the case.
The system just doesn't WORK that way. You CANNOT simulate real world physics with D20. It's pointless. If you want to do that, and have PCs that can do no more, no less than real world persons, take a system like Gurps or suchlike. Really.
Trying to nerf a D20 game, whether Conan or not, to a "only what you can do in real life" level is TOTALLY beside the point of a heroic fantasy game.