Well, I downloaded the fighting steel demo... yuck.
In addition to outdated graphics that made me want to barf(physically, apparently I got nauseous or something...), I had to put up with a rather non-responsive camera, horrible default camera angles, ridiculous glitches that would make me crash to desktop, and a general lack of responsiveness from my units.
I tried playing several times. First I tried a mission in the Atlantic. 3 German cruisers against Norfolk and Suffolk(I played Germans). All was going well to start, I increased speed to 29 knots, and then the lead ship in the line made contact with the enemy. I set gunnery orders to whatever, and ordered the use of AP rounds for all 3 of my ships. I saw my ships fire a total of 3 times, while I must have seen countless salvos come in from Norfolk and Suffolk, especially when we were so close to eachother that any secondary guns that I might have had(but didnt...) could have been brought to bear at point-blank. Then I thought, HEY TORPEDOS, and attempted that, and crashed to desktop....
I tried that one again.... this time avoiding torpedos, and deciding to try to change my course.... which never happened because I crashed to friggin desktop when I hit the compass...
Then I tried a Jap v. American scenario, with Kongo and some other assorted ships against a group of smaller American craft. I played Japs. I was like, oh Battleship, I can sorta live with this! But I encountered the same problems. Not shooting when I ordered them too, not turning when I ordered them to(I was able to use those turn arrow things in the middle of the compass, but thats about it), even when I chose the targets, when they did finally fire, they either missed, or scored direct hits which seemed to do absolutely no damage to the enemy (Kongos forward guns against an American destroyer, I saw 4 explosions from my shells, meaning 4 hits in my mind, but 0 damage to the destroyer) at which point I got pissed and uninstalled the game... well, I tried torpedos again first, but then crashed to desktop AND THEN uninstalled the game...
After that, I checked out Enigma Rising Tide and Silent Hunter 3 and 4, but unfortunately, I don't think I can run any of the 3 games, despite my interest in them.... and there doesn't seem to be a Surcouf in any of the 3 games...