Dredd Times
Administrator
Having not only created this thread but also following it carefully its nice to see varied responces to what people would and would not like to see come out as JD material.
Sourcebooks
It is obivous that a lot of people seem to want more products based around Mega-City One itself rather than Luna-1, Atlantis or Oz, etc and thats a great idea. Judge Dredd is the toughest lawman in the year 2225, but take away Mega-City One and he is little more than a thug with a badge and a gun and a bad attitude. Dredd would be nothing without his city, in much the same way other icons such as say the Doctor would be lost without his TARDIS, and products do need to relflect the city in all its glory.
That said there are many other angles from which to approach the universe of Judge Dredd, little has been written on East-Meg Two, Sino-Cit or Oz, all of which have featured more than once in the comics long history and all have a wealth of background just waiting to come to the surface.
Books such as Matts Undercity will no doubt add an extra element that is missing from the core rules and expand playablity for those who wish to pursue life below the Big Meg, and the up coming articles in Signs and Portents will feature new and expanded rules for features taken from the core product, as well as new profiles and backgrounds for well know perps.
Perps
It isnt easy coming up with expanded backgrounds for perps in Dredd as he either kills them or they go to the cubes, and with the exception of Mean Machine and Chopper only Death comes close to eluding the character for any length of time. So unless you go back and re-write the histories of characters year by year it can be difficult to avoid the obivious 'Hes Dead' Shes doing 40'.
Background Material
John (Caliber) and I had the idea late last year of writing a year book for each year that would detail events of note that had taken place during that current year, so the first book of the series would have been 2224 and followed by this years current 2225 and so on. Also we thought it would be good to go back to year one and work out back history for some of the lesser know characters and such, and lead up to books detailing important events such as the Apocalypse War.
Sure not everyone is going to want to buy a book that will cover the details of an event that has already happened, but take a look at the Babylon 5 range and you will see that it is an excellent idea, and can not only be fun for the reader but also the author too.
I do intend on working on an Academy guide at some point, in which characters are cadets rather than full eagled judges, and also developing Sector 190 in further detail. Dredd Times has a few ideas for the Academy already up with Red Wing, including a few npcs, and more material will go up as soon as I can get around to finishing off what I have in my files.
Artist Issues
Original artwork vs comic art? Well I collect 2000AD and have almost a full run of both it and its sister comic the Megazine now, plus all the annuals, graphic novels, toys, etc. I always look forward to seeing all new artwork and John did some stunning work in all of the Rookies Guides including my own book Crazes, but I do feel that this is a question of money rather than anything else. When you have access to the full range of comic material, its a little pointles to then pay someone to create a new image for you unless its a completly new idea, and more money forked out for new art means less to spend on new products in the long run.
New Blood
There are a lot of gamers out there who play games such as Dredd and Slaine who want to see all new material, products that are based on something that has not been seen in the comics and is completley new! This again is a great idea but one that is not as profitable for a company as expanding on already created material. Concerned Dredd player states that he/she hopes that Mongoose wont come up with a world trade guide, and thats fine if you dont wish to see it, but there are perhaps more people who would be interested in seeing the world of Dredd expanded to include such details. Players of D&D always want to learn more about their favorite realm and what happens in it, so why not carry on the trend in science fiction roleplaying? I am not suggesting a full product about trade and commerce here, or that you run a campaign based around a firm of real estate brookers, just simply that there is always room in any game for expansion.
Battle Royale
Also the mention of sales of the Dredd line vs the old GW product! Well in the space of two months of the Mongoose games release it had already out matched the Games Workshop game in quantity of releases, and they held the licesne for over six years! I am not sure just how many copies of the game have been sold and its not my place to question such a thing in any case, but the Mongoose game is being well recived by gamers the world over so something must be right! I know many don't like d20 and I can understand why, but when all is said and done these rules are not concrete just guidelines and I am sure that if you do use your own house rules that Matthew isnt going to come around with the SJS and get heavy with the daysticks!
At the moment Dredd and Slaine seem to be on the back burner, with very few products being listed for release right now. Mongoose are naturally concentrating on bigger fish with Babylon 5 and Conan, but support will continue for both Dredd and Slaine, albeit in a diluted fashion. Just because there hasn't been a new Dredd product out since Feburary does not mean that the line is over for good!
Fan Sites
I am really pleased that Dredd is back on shelves of games stores and more than happy to continue to support it by writing new material for both comercial release and free to download products if possible. I do agree that there is a distinct lack of fan based sites around right now, especially for Slaine, and I would welcome the addition of any new fan site for either game with open arms. I will carry on supporting Dredd even if Mongoose do give up or lose the license and will try to take on board a lot of the suggestions that have been raised on the board during this thread and others.
Just a few words, thanks for all the imput on this thread
Marc
Sourcebooks
It is obivous that a lot of people seem to want more products based around Mega-City One itself rather than Luna-1, Atlantis or Oz, etc and thats a great idea. Judge Dredd is the toughest lawman in the year 2225, but take away Mega-City One and he is little more than a thug with a badge and a gun and a bad attitude. Dredd would be nothing without his city, in much the same way other icons such as say the Doctor would be lost without his TARDIS, and products do need to relflect the city in all its glory.
That said there are many other angles from which to approach the universe of Judge Dredd, little has been written on East-Meg Two, Sino-Cit or Oz, all of which have featured more than once in the comics long history and all have a wealth of background just waiting to come to the surface.
Books such as Matts Undercity will no doubt add an extra element that is missing from the core rules and expand playablity for those who wish to pursue life below the Big Meg, and the up coming articles in Signs and Portents will feature new and expanded rules for features taken from the core product, as well as new profiles and backgrounds for well know perps.
Perps
It isnt easy coming up with expanded backgrounds for perps in Dredd as he either kills them or they go to the cubes, and with the exception of Mean Machine and Chopper only Death comes close to eluding the character for any length of time. So unless you go back and re-write the histories of characters year by year it can be difficult to avoid the obivious 'Hes Dead' Shes doing 40'.
Background Material
John (Caliber) and I had the idea late last year of writing a year book for each year that would detail events of note that had taken place during that current year, so the first book of the series would have been 2224 and followed by this years current 2225 and so on. Also we thought it would be good to go back to year one and work out back history for some of the lesser know characters and such, and lead up to books detailing important events such as the Apocalypse War.
Sure not everyone is going to want to buy a book that will cover the details of an event that has already happened, but take a look at the Babylon 5 range and you will see that it is an excellent idea, and can not only be fun for the reader but also the author too.
I do intend on working on an Academy guide at some point, in which characters are cadets rather than full eagled judges, and also developing Sector 190 in further detail. Dredd Times has a few ideas for the Academy already up with Red Wing, including a few npcs, and more material will go up as soon as I can get around to finishing off what I have in my files.
Artist Issues
Original artwork vs comic art? Well I collect 2000AD and have almost a full run of both it and its sister comic the Megazine now, plus all the annuals, graphic novels, toys, etc. I always look forward to seeing all new artwork and John did some stunning work in all of the Rookies Guides including my own book Crazes, but I do feel that this is a question of money rather than anything else. When you have access to the full range of comic material, its a little pointles to then pay someone to create a new image for you unless its a completly new idea, and more money forked out for new art means less to spend on new products in the long run.
New Blood
There are a lot of gamers out there who play games such as Dredd and Slaine who want to see all new material, products that are based on something that has not been seen in the comics and is completley new! This again is a great idea but one that is not as profitable for a company as expanding on already created material. Concerned Dredd player states that he/she hopes that Mongoose wont come up with a world trade guide, and thats fine if you dont wish to see it, but there are perhaps more people who would be interested in seeing the world of Dredd expanded to include such details. Players of D&D always want to learn more about their favorite realm and what happens in it, so why not carry on the trend in science fiction roleplaying? I am not suggesting a full product about trade and commerce here, or that you run a campaign based around a firm of real estate brookers, just simply that there is always room in any game for expansion.
Battle Royale
Also the mention of sales of the Dredd line vs the old GW product! Well in the space of two months of the Mongoose games release it had already out matched the Games Workshop game in quantity of releases, and they held the licesne for over six years! I am not sure just how many copies of the game have been sold and its not my place to question such a thing in any case, but the Mongoose game is being well recived by gamers the world over so something must be right! I know many don't like d20 and I can understand why, but when all is said and done these rules are not concrete just guidelines and I am sure that if you do use your own house rules that Matthew isnt going to come around with the SJS and get heavy with the daysticks!
At the moment Dredd and Slaine seem to be on the back burner, with very few products being listed for release right now. Mongoose are naturally concentrating on bigger fish with Babylon 5 and Conan, but support will continue for both Dredd and Slaine, albeit in a diluted fashion. Just because there hasn't been a new Dredd product out since Feburary does not mean that the line is over for good!
Fan Sites
I am really pleased that Dredd is back on shelves of games stores and more than happy to continue to support it by writing new material for both comercial release and free to download products if possible. I do agree that there is a distinct lack of fan based sites around right now, especially for Slaine, and I would welcome the addition of any new fan site for either game with open arms. I will carry on supporting Dredd even if Mongoose do give up or lose the license and will try to take on board a lot of the suggestions that have been raised on the board during this thread and others.
Just a few words, thanks for all the imput on this thread
Marc