>Why is that MGF or less MGF? The half-man, half-wolf
>werewolf is a byproduct of special effects limitations in
>the 1930s (Lon Chaney Jr. was a great make-up artist
>but he couldn't make himself look like a wolf - and
>dogs look silly as werewolves).
Only to explain were i came from.
There are two possibilities:
1) ALL Hsunchen only can turn into their totem animals, not piece by piece. The Telmori are no exception of that rule, except that the cursed ones turn unwillingly on Wildday.
That assumes that everything we have on them since 1979 is outdated, all campaigns played since then wrong.
2) ALL Hsunchen can turn into their totem animals piece by piece. The Telmori can do this as well, except that the cursed ones shapechange completely unwillingly on Wildday.
That would continue all we know of the Hsunchen/Telmori we know of them since 1979, and continues the way almost all campaigns have handled them so far.
You might be right about the origin of the wolfman creature look (but you also might be wrong: film "The Wolfeman" 1941... book "The Werewolf of Paris" 1935), but if Telmori can only turn into normal wolves they are nothing special anymore.
A single wolf is no thread, but a single (monster movie) werewolf is.
I would like to keep my Telmori as horror movie creatures, at least the cursed ones.
IMHO it is less fun for PLAYING in Glorantha if you only can shapechange into the totem animal completely. It might work better for fiction, but for playing in Glorantha i find it more MGF my way.
>The Gloranthan hsunchen take animal form. Not piece
>by piece, but entirely. The piece by piece thing is an
>unfortunate legacy of RQ2/3.
The Telmor Cult, including the piece by piece transformation, was published in "Dorastor - Land of Doom". At the editorial page it says the Telmor Cult was written by Sandy Petersen, Greg Stafford, ... .
Not everything written in fiction works as good as written in a roleplaying book. I go the MGF way, and the movie kind of werewolfs are more MGF that the "turn into a normal wolf" werewolfs in my opinion.
But as Greg says: Your Glorantha May Vary!
Cheers
Osentalka