You don't actually have an 'All of the above' button on your vote. I have played loads of Star ship war games some of which didn't make your list (we even looked at Traveller's space combat once - it seemd to make more sense when read sideways). Some of them are a lot better than others, some of them are utter madness.
I like ACTA due to its simple rules, fast and easy to play and not being a chore to pick two or more pretty balanced fleets. It has a similar warm fuzzy feeling to it that Epic Space Marine (when GW combined Titan Legions and Space Marine and made the rules work) had when it was released. If I want to play the detailed few on few, I still own B5 Wars.
What I would like to see Mongoose do is a lot more complex fighter based game (a use for those big AOG fighter mould they own) where you take a wing or two of fighters against each other. One of those where it is 1-2 hits will kill a fighter, but you have the tools to make it as hard as possible to be hit while hitting your opponent. (anyone ever play that Star Wars based one called Star Warriors)
Also try out this link you just might find something you like somewhere on it.
Edit: I remembered the name was Star Warriors - My Google-fu needs improving
I like ACTA due to its simple rules, fast and easy to play and not being a chore to pick two or more pretty balanced fleets. It has a similar warm fuzzy feeling to it that Epic Space Marine (when GW combined Titan Legions and Space Marine and made the rules work) had when it was released. If I want to play the detailed few on few, I still own B5 Wars.
What I would like to see Mongoose do is a lot more complex fighter based game (a use for those big AOG fighter mould they own) where you take a wing or two of fighters against each other. One of those where it is 1-2 hits will kill a fighter, but you have the tools to make it as hard as possible to be hit while hitting your opponent. (anyone ever play that Star Wars based one called Star Warriors)
Also try out this link you just might find something you like somewhere on it.
Edit: I remembered the name was Star Warriors - My Google-fu needs improving