Armies of the Fifth Frontier War, Impressions Not Errata

[MasterGwydion]

They use makers to make spares...

Your Army is equipped to TL7, you do not mass produce TL5 spares. You build repair factories at every IN base, Imperial Waystaion, you may even build TL15 military factories on lower TL worlds.

And then we got to the industrial revolution and the pace of change accelerated.

And they were easily defeated on the battlefield.

How many horse mounted units are now maintained for frontline battle?

The Imperium has been TL15 for over a hundred years, it has been TL14 for three centuries before that, a period where it has fought peer opponents on three occasions. By the start of the FFW the Imperial Army is TL15, the Imperial Navy is TL15, with a 100 years of stockpiling, 100 years to build repair facilities and parts manufacturer. It has the population and industrial base to do this easily.

This! Thank you @Sigtrygg

 

[MonsterX]

They use makers to make spares...

Your Army is equipped to TL7, you do not mass produce TL5 spares. You build repair factories at every IN base, Imperial Waystaion, you may even build TL15 military factories on lower TL worlds.

And then we got to the industrial revolution and the pace of change accelerated.

And they were easily defeated on the battlefield.

How many horse mounted units are now maintained for frontline battle?

The Imperium has been TL15 for over a hundred years, it has been TL14 for three centuries before that, a period where it has fought peer opponents on three occasions. By the start of the FFW the Imperial Army is TL15, the Imperial Navy is TL15, with a 100 years of stockpiling, 100 years to build repair facilities and parts manufacturer. It has the population and industrial base to do this easily.

If it were the case that you could turn out new equipment with a few TL 15 makers, then there would not be anything but TL 15 worlds in the Imperium. You can plausibly argue that it should be like that, since by the time period of the game we will probably have achieved a post-scarcity society, but that is not the premise of the game. TL 15 factories for military production on lower TL worlds are a plausible partial solution, and there is support in Traveller canon, but those will only work by shipping in lots of inputs from TL 15 worlds (otherwise we are doing away with the premise that some (most) worlds are lower tech)

Indeed during the industrial revolution the pace of change accelerated. If you want to assume it will stay like it is now, we'll be at TL 1000 by the time of the FFW. Which is totally plausible, in fact in my opinion it is more likely to be what happens if mankind actually survives that long, but it is also not the premise of the game, mainly because it wouldn't be a fun space opera.

Horse cavalry was successfully used in WWII for certain operations by less mechanized armies, but its use became more and more limited, due to its role being taken over by mechanized vehicles, its vulnerability to air power, and the fact that fewer and fewer people were learning to ride horses. It was considered effective by certain combatants, though others phased it out. Not really relevant to the point I am making because 19th century examples would serve just as well for the point I am making, but I wanted to be accurate. Read up if you want to know more.

On the last point, I agree they would have stockpiles of TL 15 equipment. However, if you accept the premise that there are worlds lower than TL 15 then you seem to be asserting these worlds must have unlimited amounts of TL 15 gear in their frontier warehouses. Otherwise, their limited stockpiles will run out at some point. Or be blown up or captured by Zhodani. Once the Zhodani have your magic TL 15 warehouses that provide unlimited equipment, you'll be in trouble. However, if you put those magic bottomless warehouses behind the lines where the Zhodani can't get them, then you're back to the logistics problem - you have to ship it to the front line. More likely, you have a certain amount of gear on hand, and when you run out, or it gets destroyed, you might try to ship in more but you will get disruptions, at which point you either surrender or rely on local production.

 

[MasterGwydion]

If it were the case that you could turn out new equipment with a few TL 15 makers, then there would not be anything but TL 15 worlds in the Imperium. You can plausibly argue that it should be like that, since by the time period of the game we will probably have achieved a post-scarcity society, but that is not the premise of the game. TL 15 factories for military production on lower TL worlds are a plausible partial solution, and there is support in Traveller canon, but those will only work by shipping in lots of inputs from TL 15 worlds (otherwise we are doing away with the premise that some (most) worlds are lower tech)

Indeed during the industrial revolution the pace of change accelerated. If you want to assume it will stay like it is now, we'll be at TL 1000 by the time of the FFW. Which is totally plausible, in fact in my opinion it is more likely to be what happens if mankind actually survives that long, but it is also not the premise of the game, mainly because it wouldn't be a fun space opera.

Horse cavalry was successfully used in WWII for certain operations by less mechanized armies, but its use became more and more limited, due to its role being taken over by mechanized vehicles, its vulnerability to air power, and the fact that fewer and fewer people were learning to ride horses. It was considered effective by certain combatants, though others phased it out. Not really relevant to the point I am making because 19th century examples would serve just as well for the point I am making, but I wanted to be accurate. Read up if you want to know more.

On the last point, I agree they would have stockpiles of TL 15 equipment. However, if you accept the premise that there are worlds lower than TL 15 then you seem to be asserting these worlds must have unlimited amounts of TL 15 gear in their frontier warehouses. Otherwise, their limited stockpiles will run out at some point. Or be blown up or captured by Zhodani. Once the Zhodani have your magic TL 15 warehouses that provide unlimited equipment, you'll be in trouble. However, if you put those magic bottomless warehouses behind the lines where the Zhodani can't get them, then you're back to the logistics problem - you have to ship it to the front line. More likely, you have a certain amount of gear on hand, and when you run out, or it gets destroyed, you might try to ship in more but you will get disruptions, at which point you either surrender or rely on local production.

What you seem to be failing to grasp is Capitalism and the difference between military spending and household spending.

The military doesn't care how much it costs. I am sure Patton tanks are much cheaper than the M-1, but you don't see the US using Pattons. From 1979 to 1997 Pattons went from the primary armor of the US Army to being non-existent and replaced with the M-1. 18 years from development completion to fully replacing the Patton.

I also know plenty of people who can't afford the best. My wife uses a manual can opener, manual meat grinder. Most people here drive motorcycles or scooters instead of cars, because they can't afford them. You never see that with the military.

So, if I can buy a TL-6 house for $10,000 or a TL-15 house for $1,000,000 and I only make $15,000 a year? Which am I buying? That is the difference between civilian and military spending. Also, civilians don't have to worry about their purchases being resistant to weapons.

As for transportation? You seem to have forgotten what the "Subsidized" in "Subsidized Merchant" stands for.

 

[Vormaerin]

What manufacturing at TL15 is like, why some worlds are lower tech, what "lower tech" even means in a space faring trade federation, and a bunch of other factors that we would need the answer to are, in fact, not known and no one in Traveller publishing has tried to answer them effectively.

There should, imho, be a provincial army of locally equipped units with standards designed to theoretically (hah) allow some level of effective integration with the Imperial Army. IIRC, some of the press releases about the insurgency on Efate back in the 1980s denied that *regular Army* units were being deployed there.

The actual Imperial Army is not scattered all over every world in the Imperium, just like the Imperial Navy isn't. It's probably concentrated on worlds with ongoing conflicts, fortress worlds, and higher tech worlds that serve as logistical hubs. The FFW game does not suggest that the Imperial Army's main units are some absolutely enormous force relative to the area it protects. Quite the contrary.

It seems quite reasonable to me that they have a substantial (but not infinite or ubiquitous) force in being equipped at the current state of the Art (TL 15). There are enough TL 15 worlds and enough portable manufacturing enclave capability to do that.

Will a protracted conflict on the Imperial Fringe lead to localized force degradation due to logistical issues? Most likely. Does that have anything to do with the state of the forces in being during peacetime? Only tangentially, in that there is probably some plan for dealing with these expected logistical problems. It's not like this is the first Frontier War the Imperium has fought.

But none of that leads me to think the Imperium would deliberately equip its units in an obsolete and ineffective (as best as can be determined by the game mechanics available to us) manner to fight it's major opponent.

The US may spend most of its time beating up third world countries and irregular insurgencies, but it still has to equip its military to fight proper militaries like China and Russia. The Imperium would be the same way.