An argument over a few B5 universe ideas...

[emperorpenguin]

I'd use the "2 Minbari Castes" defence myself

What happened to the other caste?

It got added

and JMS will say he had this all planned out from the beginning.... :roll:

yeah just like Chris Carter and the X files!

 

[ATimson]

and JMS will say he had this all planned out from the beginning.... :roll:

To be fair, he didn't write the episode in question, and two vs. three may have slipped by him (especially since he wasn't the story editor, so he may have not even necessarily looked at the final script).

 

[emperorpenguin]

he can't claim that for In the Beginning

 

[ATimson]

You assume that it wasn't deliberate.

(Without more details like Turloigh requested--because I didn't notice any contradictions beyond the relocating of the Black Star incident, something done because it makes more sense as shown in ItB--snark is about all I have to offer. )

 

[emperorpenguin]

you mean like Sheridan being unable to count!

4 warcruisers suddenly becomes just one! :lol:

 

[frobisher]

and JMS will say he had this all planned out from the beginning.... :roll:

To be fair, he didn't write the episode in question, and two vs. three may have slipped by him (especially since he wasn't the story editor, so he may have not even necessarily looked at the final script).

Except that it's not just one script it's in Also details like that came down from jms...

 

[wargame_insomniac]

you mean like Sheridan being unable to count!

4 warcruisers suddenly becomes just one! :lol:

I though it was 1 Sharlin & 3 Tinashi??

To an earther seeing load of own ships being blown out of the sky, I could see Tinashi being described as warcruiser.

Cheers

James

 

[emperorpenguin]

you mean like Sheridan being unable to count!

4 warcruisers suddenly becomes just one! :lol:

I though it was 1 Sharlin & 3 Tinashi??

To an earther seeing load of own ships being blown out of the sky, I could see Tinashi being described as warcruiser.

Cheers

James

yeah but there are no other ships in ITB! Just the Drala Fi! Where Sheridan gets his extra 3 kills from god knows!