Condottiere
Emperor Mongoose
Make it cheaper to have human hirelings.
Why no co-pilot?
- Thread starter Fluffy Bunny Feet
- Start date
Sageryne
Cosmic Mongoose
My players don’t want strangers on their ship.
They are not the co-pilot because Pilot skill is not a required part of the job. They ought to be the co-pilot, though. But the character creation system is not necessarily going to make that a thing.
The astrogator has always been the person who does real space navigation, the fact that they have any meaningful role in jump space navigation (instead of the computer doing it) is the innovation of later editions of Traveller. The specific task chain referenced is a Mongoose innovation.
However, there is a very good reason why every sci fi show out there that bothers with a navigator character quickly finds them some thing else to do. Notably, in Star Trek, the navigator was always the noob guy around to be stupid so the real crew could do or say something important. Until Chekov and he was given fire control responsibilities before too long. Star Wars implies that the pilot is doing navigation, but it never happens on screen. And so on.
I have a question about your quote. There is a task for plotting a course using a gravity slingshot. Great. What does that DO? How much faster does that make the trip? How often do you have an orrery for the system the players are in so that your player can even determine if that's useful without you telling them "hey, you can actually use your astrogation skill now for something other than the usual save or die on the way to the adventure?
Classsic Traveller did not have an astrogator role as necessary for basically any player scale ship (Had to be over 200 dtons to need one) because the game offers approximately 0 support for actually using the skill in a fun and interesting way. Mongoose has now made it mandatory that someone on the crew of every starship have it, but has not done anything to make having it as your primary job skill fun. It's just a "please make the saving throw so we don't die on the way to the next cool thing" skill. Worse it managed to be that and also just a modifier to someone else's task check to actually do the thing.
IMHO, the difference between Pilot (starship) and Pilot (Small craft) cascade should be the astrogation training and Astrogation should just go away as a separate skill. Or, if that's too radical, it should be an additional cascade slot on the Pilot skill.
Fluffy Bunny Feet
Emperor Mongoose
Or hire an NPC.If no one in My group has Pilot, I make them fly commercial.
I run about half my campaigns with the PCs not having a ship. Probably more than half if you count campaigns where the players don't start with a ship for a bunch of sessions. For example, the last campaign I ran had some loose inspiration from Islands in the Net. But the players started on Neon with a Flatlined-esque situation and had at least a dozen adventures on various worlds before they even got to the ship.
Being the pilot or the engineer of a space ship is a pretty common fantasy for players, because most space sci fi has prominent roles for such characters and it is easy to imagine what they do during an adventure.. Sadly, being an astrogator or steward doesn't seem to have the same cachet.
Being the pilot or the engineer of a space ship is a pretty common fantasy for players, because most space sci fi has prominent roles for such characters and it is easy to imagine what they do during an adventure.. Sadly, being an astrogator or steward doesn't seem to have the same cachet.
Terry Mixon
Emperor Mongoose
No clue.
Condottiere
Emperor Mongoose
As long as you're willing to take a default minus three penalty on the astrogation check, you don't need no steenkin' astrogators.
Exactly. A while back I started a thread asking how people actually make astrogation work since it's a required skill for starship based campaigns and there was basically nothing usable at the gaming table resulting from it. A number of people confused "it would be important in real life" with "it's a good skill for the game."
Fluffy Bunny Feet
Emperor Mongoose
Find ways so at least occasionally the players need to analyze jump records as part of the adventure.
MasterGwydion
Emperor Mongoose
I always figure that if I as a Referee need to work really hard to include a skill in the game, and make it fun, that the game says is required, then the skill just needs to go away and be rolled into another skill, like Pilot (starships)
Condottiere
Emperor Mongoose
I'd see what subskills are being specialized.
Core skills that are a required role in a typical game ought to be things that a player can use proactively, not something that the GM needs to toss out to the player from time to time. There's enough of those skills already.
Everyone knows what the pilot does and when their skill is likely to be relevant. Same with Engineer, Medic. Hell, even Steward. What are the opportunities for the player to go "You know, this is the perfect opportunity to use that my Astrogation skill"? If a skill is so abstruse that the GM has to inform the player that this is a chance to use it, it's a bad skill for a game.
Game design is a choice. Traveller chose to make Astrogation its own distinct skill in a game where PCs are typically not going to have a lot of skill ranks. Further, Mongoose chose to make it mandatory on PC ships, when it didn't use to be (unless you had a lab ship or a fat trader). Therefore, they need to develop a use case for it besides "don't take a wrong turn at Albuquerque on the way to the adventure."
If you can use it advantage in real space navigation, give the players practical examples of how they can do that. And what it will do. If you can use it as part of skip tracing ships, show how so the player knows. If it gives an advantage in Reginan Roulette, say that.
Because just existing to be a chance to screw up the jump is worse than CT where it wasn't necessary at all.
Everyone knows what the pilot does and when their skill is likely to be relevant. Same with Engineer, Medic. Hell, even Steward. What are the opportunities for the player to go "You know, this is the perfect opportunity to use that my Astrogation skill"? If a skill is so abstruse that the GM has to inform the player that this is a chance to use it, it's a bad skill for a game.
Game design is a choice. Traveller chose to make Astrogation its own distinct skill in a game where PCs are typically not going to have a lot of skill ranks. Further, Mongoose chose to make it mandatory on PC ships, when it didn't use to be (unless you had a lab ship or a fat trader). Therefore, they need to develop a use case for it besides "don't take a wrong turn at Albuquerque on the way to the adventure."
If you can use it advantage in real space navigation, give the players practical examples of how they can do that. And what it will do. If you can use it as part of skip tracing ships, show how so the player knows. If it gives an advantage in Reginan Roulette, say that.
Because just existing to be a chance to screw up the jump is worse than CT where it wasn't necessary at all.
Condottiere
Emperor Mongoose
Going by the current rules, you could make an astrogation check without knowing the skill.
Just, at minus three.
And, you could keep at it, until one result clicks.
Just, at minus three.
And, you could keep at it, until one result clicks.
