Sgt_G said:
Well, in the deck plans I'm working on, I do have every bed and desk and table mapped out. I put that stuff in there so as to be able to guage whether or not the rooms were the "right" size. I suppose I could have deleted them after, but what the heck -- the Police Cutter is the smallest ship in the fleet, so I would presume its deck plans would be published at a larger scale than most warships.
Question is: just how much detail would players want? Example: I still need to fill Sick Bay with all the beds and such. Do players want that, or is it a waste of my time? I could just leave a big 12x19 meter empty box, put text "SICK BAY" in it, and call it a day. If you just want empty boxes with text saying what the rooms are, I can finish this project tomorrow. But if you want / think-you-need all the beds and chairs marked, I have a bit more to do. Check out the topic on the SFB discussion board.
I was just looking at Nick Blank's Fed FFG deck plans, and they're a bit of a mix: a lot of rooms have beds & chairs marked, others just have a text label. Then again, the FFG has about 60% more deck area / floor space than the POL does.
It really does depend on the size of the ship, and the scale you're reasonably able to represent on the page. Personally, I think the approach in the FFG, D7 and Skyhawk (for instance) on that page look great and do the job.
The Tholian
may be good, but the images in that PDF are so low a resolution that it's impossible to read, all the detail is lost. I didn't see anything in your design docs about image resolution specifically, so hopefully no one is working and submitting their work in 72 dpi. Example: Snipe plans, can barely make out a thing. Right amount of detail, but can't be read because of the resolution. Will look awful on paper if that's the master copy.
Related to that, beds in sickbay? Will you really be able to make out those details clearly when it is printed out? Or is the ship so big that a better approach would be just to have a blank room with a label, and perhaps a callout close-up view showing details of key rooms (bridge, sickbay, typical bunk, bay). But if the effective printed size of your sickbay in the plans is as small as a square centimeter, the label is more important than the beds. Just my opinion, but the level of detail shown in the Free Trader on that page seems just fine to me. It all depends on whether these are for book or some larger printed deckplan project.
But again, all this work will be for nothing if the images used are not print resolution. Matt and the Mongoose folks know all about this.
I have no idea what's going on behind the scenes, or if these particular plans were even intended for the Traveller
D book, but it looks to me like you guys are closer to finished than we may have thought.