Zager Krahl
Mongoose
Oh yes you would...
redsimon said:Now that we know there are bonus adventures, why would anyone want the books without?
Bleeding said:About overall balance, I think the ranger is not very balanced. At his last rank, he can fight with a bow, doubling damages, adding 10 CS with his bow and 10 more CS against a chosen enemy...
That's exactly the point: Italians too have the bonus adventures (at least n. 2-4, the others have not been published yet and probably never will) and they only cost 10 euros, more or less.redsimon said:Btw, the German edition of the current CE has softcover with the bonus adventures included. We will probably never see hardbacks, but everybody seems happy with the quality softcover (it's better than the average softcover, harder and more flexible) as I never heard/read otherwise.
Now that we know there are bonus adventures, why would anyone want the books without?
Publishing stopped at volume 4? That is harsh.RatedRWolf said:That's exactly the point: Italians too have the bonus adventures (at least n. 2-4, the others have not been published yet and probably never will) and they only cost 10 euros, more or less.
Yep, that's exactly why there is no reason to now publish a softcover light version. Why would you follow up a better version with a worse one? To refer to Random Code: Usually the DVDs without bonus material are published before OR at the same time like the ones with that material. Or albums with bonus tracks are mostly published later like some kind of updated versions.If paperbacks had been published only a few weeks after the CEs I'd have understood the lack of the bonus adventures but... come on! 3 years and a half have passed since Flight from the Dark has come out, there's no reason not to add the Bonus Adventures to the softocover: each and every single customer who could have bought the CE has already done it...
Bleeding said:I stopped buying before Sommerlund. I'm waiting for the Bestiary to order them both and all the books so far are very enjoyable.
And you're right, the rules light system is very flexible.
I added a skill system and it remains 100% compatible with your books.
About overall balance, I think the ranger is not very balanced. At his last rank, he can fight with a bow, doubling damages, adding 10 CS with his bow and 10 more CS against a chosen enemy...
Deadlier than most fighters...
You're doing a good job nonetheless and I hope this game will last for years![]()
redsimon said:Yep, that's exactly why there is no reason to now publish a softcover light version. Why would you follow up a better version with a worse one?
Greg Smith said:redsimon said:Yep, that's exactly why there is no reason to now publish a softcover light version. Why would you follow up a better version with a worse one?
Widespread distribution at a lower price?
redsimon said:Usually the DVDs without bonus material are published before OR at the same time like the ones with that material. Or albums with bonus tracks are mostly published later like some kind of updated versions.
Random Code said:I also think alot of people of attaching more value to these bonus adventures than they are worth, as well. They are generally okay but nothing amazingly special. YMMV.
I would have agreed if the CEs had been published just two months ago, but knowing that there will be at least four years between the hardcover and the softcover edition, there's no need to distinguish them in such a way. In my opinion, Mongoose should behave just as every normal publishing company behaves: I have never seen a paperback edition different from the hardcover one...BlackCat said:I'm pretty happy that only the CE will have the bonus adventures. After all, what is the point of buying the CE if the only difference is the hardcover? With the bonus adventures, I think these books deserve the CE appellation.
Disgruntled CE purchasers? Well, the purchasers of the softback version without bonus adventures have waited several years longer than the CE purchasers (if it is released). Isn't that enough to justify a new version with bonus adventures? I think it is.Random Code said:3) Including the bonus adventure would increase the price of the standard books and Mongoose may get some disgruntled CE purchasers, as well, as they'd be going back on their word that the CE would only contain the bonus adventures.
redsimon said:Disgruntled CE purchasers? Well, the purchasers of the softback version without bonus adventures have waited several years longer than the CE purchasers (if it is released). Isn't that enough to justify a new version with bonus adventures? I think it is.
RatedRWolf said:I would have agreed if the CEs had been published just two months ago, but knowing that there will be at least four years between the hardcover and the softcover edition, there's no need to distinguish them in such a way. In my opinion, Mongoose should behave just as every normal publishing company behaves: I have never seen a paperback edition different from the hardcover one...BlackCat said:I'm pretty happy that only the CE will have the bonus adventures. After all, what is the point of buying the CE if the only difference is the hardcover? With the bonus adventures, I think these books deserve the CE appellation.
The Wolf said:I have a soft spot for book 8's bonus adventure, but that's a given.
RatedRWolf said:I would have agreed if the CEs had been published just two months ago, but knowing that there will be at least four years between the hardcover and the softcover edition, there's no need to distinguish them in such a way. In my opinion, Mongoose should behave just as every normal publishing company behaves: I have never seen a paperback edition different from the hardcover one...BlackCat said:I'm pretty happy that only the CE will have the bonus adventures. After all, what is the point of buying the CE if the only difference is the hardcover? With the bonus adventures, I think these books deserve the CE appellation.
RatedRWolf said:I have never seen a paperback edition different from the hardcover one...