Bry,
I really don't like the placing of composition points into your overall score, just like I hate having sportsmanship points in overall placement. They are both arbitory and are most subjective. My preference is to have sportsmanship and composition awards that are separate from the admiralship award. IMO sportsmanship and composition scores are the most abused form of retaliation in tournament play. A player could sit there like a lump and say nothing except for good game at the end and get a 2 for sportsmanship because he wasn't talkative enough, or someone could think he was cold, or apathetic to the game. While the Judges can overturn this, it's hard to prove that the score is incorrect.
If you want to give an award for the best painted fleet, or the best "fluff" in the fleet, go ahead, but you shouldn't punish a player who is a good admiral, but a lousy painter.
Just my 2 cents.
Dave