cerebro said:
Anyway,you know what guys...I'm done.
Why are you done?
Is it because someone suggested a slightly different approach? After all, you did ask for opinions.
I think it's a good idea. Not necessarily the "D&D vs RQ" theme, but a short animation as to why RQ is a damn good system.
Unfortunately, I haven't the time or the artistic bent to do such things, but I would love to see more of them.
cerebro said:
Yep. Is not my place to make runequest better,or complain so much about it. Good luck to mongoose with it. I will be content by running my sessions,and if the guys here don't want to play in it,so be it. I will have to play whatever they are playing.
That's a shame as you have had good ideas in the threads that I have seen. I don't necessarily agree with all your points (if I did then you'd me me) but you have invited discussion.
There are several ways of changing things:
1. Become a writer for Mongoose (Freelance or In-House)
2. Write things and post them on the internet or get them published
3. Participate in online forums
Your ad satisfies option 2 and you have satisfied option 3.
Why stop?
cerebro said:
Deleriad said:
I would say never promote a game to people by saying "you k now the game you currently play? It sucks." And never promote a game by saying what it doesn't have. All you do is irritate people who might otherwise by interested and get into my game is better than your game wars.
Ask yourself what it is you like about RQ, what it is that makes you want to play it and put that at the front.
RQII because a hero knows the right time to run.
You are never going to get people that are too happy with d&d,you need the ones that are mad at it. And there are plenty. Running or being scared only appeal to chutulu players. D&D player don't run. Almost never. Because they know that whatever is in front of them, they can kill.
Another thing is that everybody thinks they are a roleplayer,not a rollplayer. I don't think it would offend anyone.
It doesn't offend anyone, as far as I know.
Some people might wonder why they are a rollplayer because they play D&D and a roleplayer because they play RQ and I would also question that.
However, there are things that RQ does that RQ does better, in my opinion.
If you can think of those then produce similar catchy ads then that would be great.
For example, you started off by making the Levels comparison, which is a very good place to start, but ignored that completely and went to an obscure combat technique. This is not a criticism of the intent but of the punchline.
As to what could be said, that would probably degenerate into a slanging match between people who don't like D&D and people who do.