A few questions

[Finlos]

I think the idea is that you were never actually on the other side of the Asteroids /Ring and hence don't have to make a roll.....

This answer. It basically represents the cloak affecting your sensor's ability to detect 'something which appears to be over there', on the other side of the planetary ring. Then the Romulan ship uncloaks and you realize he was actually *right over there* the whole time.

The cloaked ship actually *was never* on the other side of the ring.

 

[MongooseMatt]

This answer. It basically represents the cloak affecting your sensor's ability to detect 'something which appears to be over there', on the other side of the planetary ring. Then the Romulan ship uncloaks and you realize he was actually *right over there* the whole time.

The cloaked ship actually *was never* on the other side of the ring.

This is correct!

 

[Captain Jonah]

This answer. It basically represents the cloak affecting your sensor's ability to detect 'something which appears to be over there', on the other side of the planetary ring. Then the Romulan ship uncloaks and you realize he was actually *right over there* the whole time.

The cloaked ship actually *was never* on the other side of the ring.

This is correct!

Which just goes to show that you can never trust the Roms, bunch of sneaky Bas.... erm people. Everyone else had to fly through the asteroids, they just sort of sneak past when the rocks aren't looking :lol:

Though if I ask how you fired on and damaged that cloaked ship when the ship figure was on your side of the ring when the actual ship was on the other side and safe since you cannot fire through asteroids would heads explode ? :lol:

 

[tneva82]

Which just goes to show that you can never trust the Roms, bunch of sneaky Bas.... erm people. Everyone else had to fly through the asteroids, they just sort of sneak past when the rocks aren't looking :lol:

They just flew there earlier avoiding.

When you decloak you don't THEN move. The re-positioning isn't literally ship moving there. Just revealing the spot he actually was all the time...

...X..AAAAA...Y
.......AAAAA...
.......AAAAA...

..........Z......

X being where you appear, Y where you "were", A being asteroids. Imagine your base edge being on bottom. Rather than you literally moving from Y to X you rather moved toward X from the spot Z.

Now question about how it was hit if opponent could not legally shoot at it from the real position is good one but that's price of simple rules without gazillion exceptions

 

[GalagaGalaxian]

Which just goes to show that you can never trust the Roms, bunch of sneaky Bas.... erm people. Everyone else had to fly through the asteroids, they just sort of sneak past when the rocks aren't looking :lol:

Note to Star Fleet HQ, make all minefields 7" wide. :wink:

 

[scoutdad]

Which just goes to show that you can never trust the Roms, bunch of sneaky Bas.... erm people. Everyone else had to fly through the asteroids, they just sort of sneak past when the rocks aren't looking :lol:

Note to Star Fleet HQ, make all minefields 7" wide. :wink:

Hahahaha.
Now that's funny!