Questions about Khitai Sorcery

[Sven]

Well, after reading the magic section in the newest sourcebook I am a bit confused.

There are spells for three Sorcery styles. (Oriental Magic, Necromancy, Summoning).

Many spells seem to be of the wrong style, and I miss many prerequisites.

Especially spells of the Oriental Magic Style:

Heaven' Stairway would fit better as a divination or cosmic spell.

Castle of Bamboo, Bamboo Storm and Groundrot are clearly Nature magic spells, I think.

Bamboo Doom should be a curse spell.

Necromany spells:

Verdant Mastery is a Nature Magic spell. I do not understand what this spell has to do with the magic of death.

Underworld's Stairway, again Divination or Cosmic Sorcery.

Eternal Warrior, Predestigitation, anyone?

The summoning spells look okay to me.

What do you think?

And my question to the author(s) of the magic section in Khitai: Could you look into it again?

 

[Spectator]

If you rely on the regional suppplements for spells, I have been (for the most part),somewhat unimpressed, unless you exclude Across Thunder River.

 

[Sven]

If you rely on the regional suppplements for spells, I have been (for the most part),somewhat unimpressed, unless you exclude Across Thunder River.

Some spells are good, some are bad.

But usually they fit into the sorcery style, and they have prerequisites. The khitan spells look like they were only hastily written and then they were not finalized.