Garran said:
That might have been the original idea, but I can see a few good reasons not to go with it:
Using Hroal that many times would be narratively awkward (he'd be figuring into three adventures by default), and would also cause an issue if he was eliminated (somewhat likely in ToS) in one of the stories and then needed in another one - using a different Aslan avoids that issue. Aslan pirates are also supposed to be somewhat common in the Reach, and the main way that's going to happen is by way of becoming outcast (because the honorable ones are ihatei and/or their retainers), so it isn't THAT strange that two of them show up throughout the overall storyline.
I get these points: Hroal would be prominent and it would be a nuisance to the referee, if he'd be kille, before his story arc could play out.
But the opposites are true as well: Having a recurring Aslan pirate gives him a decisive role to play in the campaign, potentially making him an arch-nemesis or key ally. Are Aslan pirates somewhat common in the Reach? Yes, and they should be. But they're not just pirates, that's only what humans call them. Aslan pirates are outcasts of their society, but still Aslan, which makes them long for territory. It's explicitly remarked for Hroal in
Honour Among Thieves. That trait and motive could make him a powerful figure: Do the players offer him land on one of their early acquisitions for the new Drinaxian Kingdom (or even: Sindalian Empire) in exchange for his services? Or does he indeed become their bitter enemy and will actually become the leader of
ihatei, who leeds the assault on Drinax itself during the final battle of the campaign?
The PCs also potentially need to make an alliance with the various captains in The Treasure of Sindal. It's going to be awkward at best when one of them is Petyr and another is an Aslan - but given that Petyr and Hroal have a 'special relationship', it's unlikely that that meeting in space would end in anything other than a shooting match, derailing the entire segment. Faihlokh is also a throwaway at the end of it, winding up dead when he tries to cash in, which seems unlikely of Hroal.
All of this gives me the feeling that Faihlokh is just a stand in. His psion is fleshed out more (a couple of sentences at least plus stats), but Faihlokh himself is not. He's not even clearly a pirate by his write-up, more a fortune hunter resorting to piracy frequently.
Just making Hroal another disposable Aslan pirate just doesn't give him credit, I think. Plus, there is this very specific set-up of an Aslan pirate captain and a psion-lieutenant as his second. It's just so specific:
Psion seconds who are powerful telepaths also seem to be a running theme/gag in the adventures; it isn't just the Aslan pirate captains who keep them around! On the other hand, Hroal's psion isn't specifically described as being a major figure in his organization IIRC, so they could just be one of his low-end gang members or even a hired 'specialist'. (Hroal doesn't appear to be terribly picky about things like that...)
And in my mind, that is adding injury to insult. Having Ogleby and Hroal's psion plus Faihlokh and Dai Kinnear is just too much "coincidence", unless psions are much more common in a referee's Traveller universe than in OTU. Now, I see many remedies for that. One could be that Faihlokh was a lieutenant of Hroal and established his own posse after Hroal bit the dust in Treasure Ship, taking Dai with him. That would explain it all, flesh out both NPCs and tone down the psion overpopulation. Or one could just leave out Dai, because she is simply not needed. Whatever she does for Faihlokh, Petyr and his posse can do it without a psion. So spying on the Travellers or following them should be possible for Faihlokh as it is possible for Petyr, too.
I like the idea of Faihlokh being a former lieutenant of Hroal more though. It needs changes in the background stories of Faihlokh and Dai, but that does not change the story or what the players know. I am also thinking about making Faihlokh a female Aslan, maybe Hroal's purser, head technician or something similar. And Dai being a Mardukian comes in handy, too. The planet is featured in
Marooned on Marduk, after all.