alex_greene said:
Yeah. When in doubt, let's have a war. I hated 55W because it was just something the player characters suffered, like a really bad rainstorm everywhere they went. There was no sense of their being able to influence the course of the war; it was just a backdrop.
To be fair I don't really think there are a lot of RPGs out there taking place in the background of a war where the PCs have a major input on the outcome.
Notable exceptions being Star Wars (if you play the Luke Skywalker-
fac simile who shoots the exhaust pipe of the Death Star), Lord of the Rings (
fac-simile Frodo or Aragorn). But these all have bad guys with a Deux Ex Machina type bullseye you can hit to make the whole structure come down.
In a more "realistic" war, the only way PCs will have a direct and forceful effect on it is if they are the ones running it as the Generals, Admirals or Politicians.
But then the game tends to become more of a Wargame with a social/role-playing component as it focuses less on the PCs personally and more on the Trillion Credit Squadrons they have under their command.
Yet another problem is that if the outcome of a major war is not pre-scripted but dependent on the actions of the PCs, they can very well (and often do) screw up royaly. And then the consequences, unlike those of more mundade, run-of-the-mill adventuring screw-ups, are not limited to the PCs themselves but to the whole setting. And that's a can of worms I think most GMs aren't willing to open...having to re-write a setting on account of player failure.
So I do not think we will be seeing a Mongoose product about the 5th Frontier War where the outcome will depend on the actions of PCs. We might get adventures where very small parts of it (like the fate of a platoon of soldiers or a single city in a planet) might depend from PC action, but will be inconsequential in the major scheme of things on the long run.
Then again, I'm just tossing my 2$ here. It might be that MG will surprise us all with an epic release about the 5th Frontier War where the whole thing ultimately stands or falls on the PCs.