msprange said:Just waiting for it to come back from print!
FreeTrav said:Sadly, I feel that Mr Carr has an inflated idea of the value of his work; every item he's written that I've wanted has been priced high enough that I've looked once and said "I don't want it that badly.". The one item of his that I obtained - legally - was part of the Paratime/Lord Kalvan series, and was quite frankly mediocre at best; he is not, however much he would like to believe so, and regardless of how many hangers-on he has who tell him he is, H. Beam Piper - he's not even close.
phavoc said:I have the two Lord Kalvan books you speak of. Those I enjoyed, but I'm also a huge fan of the Paratime universe. I also have Timecop, which wasn't nearly as good at the Kalvan things. Which book were you referring to?
GypsyComet said:The Fuzzies have been that way for a while. After years of wishing someone had saved the lost third volume, one was commissioned and published from author Ardath Mayhar. Less than a year later, the lost manuscript was found.
As far as I know, Carr was only the replacement for Pournelle, whom Pi-FreeTrav said:... he is not, however much he would like to believe so, and regardless of how many hangers-on he has who tell him he is, H. Beam Piper - he's not even close.
GypsyComet said:I remember that one now. I don't recall being impressed.
Is Scalzi the one doing the new "reset" book?
rust said:As far as I know, Carr was only the replacement for Pournelle, whom Pi-FreeTrav said:... he is not, however much he would like to believe so, and regardless of how many hangers-on he has who tell him he is, H. Beam Piper - he's not even close.
per wanted to continue his series, but who unfortunately was too busy
with his own projects and his cooperation with Niven, and so handed the
work over to Carr, who - in my opinion - is not in the same league as Pi-
per or Pournelle. However, as is often the case with translated books,
perhaps Carr is better than I think, and only his translator has fumbled.
(By the way, there are also opposite cases, for me Donaldson turned out
to write much worse than his translator did.)
GypsyComet said:I remember that one now. I don't recall being impressed.
Is Scalzi the one doing the new "reset" book?
phavoc said:I was actually hoping for something of a pickup from Fuzzy Sapiens, where the Fuzzies history woudl have been explored more, or even where they showed up in a Fuzzy starship. Great Ghu!
GypsyComet said:phavoc said:I was actually hoping for something of a pickup from Fuzzy Sapiens, where the Fuzzies history woudl have been explored more, or even where they showed up in a Fuzzy starship. Great Ghu!
That would be Golden Dream, IIRC.