alexokai said:As I have already posted before, I think (as many others) that Gary Chalk's artwork is part of LW.
Could it be possible ???
I don't understand: why do you think that??? Chalk is a good artist, but no more than this and his books are less than Brian Williams' ones. The fact that GC did his job with Dever approval, doesn't make him part of LW...
alexokai said:I don't understand: why do you think that??? Chalk is a good artist, but no more than this and his books are less than Brian Williams' ones. The fact that GC did his job with Dever approval, doesn't make him part of LW...
You have to understand that it's only an opinion, I don't own the truth neither do you ...
IMO, GC artwork fits best with the world of LW. The taste for a particular artist is very subjetive ...
But you cannot say that LW without Gary Chalk would not have been LW, because it's objectively false.
I think (as many others) that Gary Chalk's artwork is part of LW.
alexokai said:Again, that's an opinion. What I said is:
I think (as many others) that Gary Chalk's artwork is part of LW.
and that is true for me. Both the texts and the art are part of my memories and I really enjoyed the books as a whole.
fly80 said:LW fitted good (and for the most part of the saga) also with Brian Williams artwork, IMO, but i will not affirm that LW without Brian Williams is not really LW: it's just an artist, like others.
Of course, you can find now some "better" illustrator but you can also find some that are WORSE (see the LWRPG rulebook for many exemples...).
Balgin Stondraeg said:Of course, you can find now some "better" illustrator but you can also find some that are WORSE (see the LWRPG rulebook for many exemples...).
I couldn't agree more. I don't like the Lone Wolf d20 illustrations (too cartoony)
Sabbak said:Balgin Stondraeg said:Of course, you can find now some "better" illustrator but you can also find some that are WORSE (see the LWRPG rulebook for many exemples...).
I couldn't agree more. I don't like the Lone Wolf d20 illustrations (too cartoony)
Excuse me!![]()
That's exactly what I mean: what I wanted to say is that I find the interior artwork of the D20 LW rulebook "not good" (to say the least...). Sorry if I haven't been very explicit...
Balgin Stondraeg said:...I prefer Gary's "monstery" monsters (you know, the really bizarre stuff).