wbnc said:
A system buying twenty SDBs is likely going to buy them stock, and negotiate a bulk purchase discount. Then upgrade them as they have the time and funds.
same for a commercial shipping firm. They'll upgrade, downgrade,and alter the stock ships as they need to, or as business situations allow them to pay for upgrades.
No, not really. Or at least that doesn't follow current reality. Today you see smaller navies purchasing warships second hand and those ships retain their equipment as much as possible. The exceptions being relatively isolated gear change outs due to age or whatnot. The reason someone buys them that way is because they can't build them on their own (or it's simply cheaper to purchase someone's paid off SDB's, do some minor repairs and put them into mainline service in your secondary or tertiary star-system).
wbnc said:
a ship like the one I am working on is a special purpose, special purchase ship...built to the upper end of the scale for buyers who need that particular type of ship. Military forces tend to be limited in their purchases by political and cost per program rather than a ship by ship basis. If a force needs cruisers they may not be able to afford a ship that is cutting edge/perfectly optimized.....even the Imperium has bean counters, and Bureaucrats/politicians who want to shave money away from one program to spend on their own pet project.
So Canon ships would tend to be the baseline, not the upper, or lower end of he scale....or at least that's my take on it.
Yah, I agree your's would be on the upper-end of the scale. To me it's built more along the lines of a warship instead of a civilian ship modified for police duties. Nothing wrong with that, as we saw in Ferguson with the cops deploying armored cars with LMG's on top. Big question comes down to what level of militarization would a planetary police force have in the future. Fortunately it would be all over the board due to the vagaries of planetary governments, so you pretty much have a free hand in designing and deploying whatever you so choose.
To me canonical ships represent average vessels for their type and class - unless they are specifically designed for a purpose. They would be what I judge my ship and any other ship by. That's how I could say "gee, this is a hunk of junk", or "gee, this is a REALLY FAST hunk of junk that can do the kessel run in 12 parsecs" - though for the latter I would put in some reasons WHY speed = distance... unlike certain movie producers... thank goodness for books!
Reynard said:
And there's the issue again. If ships are being specially built as smugger craft blazing around at top speeds, they're going to be beacons in the dark. Even fast water craft today tend to get noticed and rarely mistaken for a rich man's pleasure toy. Special built smuggling craft, by the nature of an interstellar community, are also saddled with the albatross of a jump drive which tends to blink brightly on reentry to normal space and reduce displacement significantly plus, unlike a nation's coastline, star systems have more limited 'beaching' opportunities.....
I very much agree with this! Every criminal and smuggler knows they can't fight "the man". No matter how fast your little smuggling ship is, it can't outrun radio's or military attack craft (it may get away a few times, but once it's known and identified, it's lifespan will be remarkably much shorter). Traveller has never really delved terribly deep into the relationship between the cops and the military. Since technically the 100D limit is where the sphere of ownership ends for a planet, the Imperium is responsible for navigation and safety beyond that. With the sheer volume we are talking here I don't see any Imperial ship stopping a planetary patrol craft from chasing someone they believe has broken their law beyond the 100D limit. So long as overall Imperial law was being followed I wouldn't see them blinking an eye, if not trying to help the local authorities.
Seems like an interesting area to see some write-up and such eh? Maybe a few articles in Freelance Traveller? Buehler? Buehler??