Are just asking for trouble or are we asking for help?

Dave Chase

Mongoose
http://io9.com/are-we-screwing-ourselves-by-transmitting-radio-signals-493800730

Leaky Earth?

We’ve been shouting out into the cosmos for quite some time now. Electromagnetic waves of various intensities and frequencies have been streaming away from Earth for well over a century, the remnants of TV broadcasts, mobile phone conversations, satellite transmissions, and military, civil and astronomical radars.

We’ve even deliberately tried to get ET’s attention — a controversial practice known as METI (Messaging to Extraterrestrial Intelligences). There have been many such attempts, including the 2001 Teen-Age Message to the Stars organized by the Russian cosmologist Alexander Zaitsev. His work, and those of others, have been criticized as being insanely risky given the dearth of information we have about the nature of ETIs. Two years ago, John Billingham and James Benford called for a global moratorium on METI, an initiative similar to the one David Brin and myself worked on last decade.

But now, owing to all this human activity, the Earth has a radiosphere that’s inexorably billowing outwards at the speed of light — a clear signal that’s just waiting to be picked up.

Interesting Article

Dave Chase
 
While I agree with Hawking that any direct First Contact will likely be disastrous, especially if we are still confined to Earth when it occurs, there really isn't much we can do about. The chance of physical First Contact is very low; more accurately as we only have a sample of one, the chance of contact is unknown. But I imagine the cost of preventing our radio waves from emanating throughout space would be very high. I've never seen a cost benefit analysis concerning First Contact vs. avoiding First Contact. SETI, NASA and especially the National Security Council have almost certainly come up with numerous scenarios regarding First Contact. I'll defer to them, for now.

Benjamin Lecrone
 
Back
Top