Elric RPG - oddness in summary of "Skrayling Tree"

Kamelion

Mongoose
***Spoilers for The Skrayling Tree below***


I'm leafing through the Elric RPG and finding it a great product. I do have a question unrelated to the game content, however. The brief summaries of the Elric saga are all pretty good, except for the one covering The Skrayling Tree. It states that "Ulrik von Bek... is visited by a strange albino version of himself and, when Oona is abducted by a group of Native Americans, Ulrik trails them using The Skrayling Oak... Finally the hero discovers that Gaynor the Damned, now ruling over a mob of outcasts, is behind Oona’s abduction."

As anyone who has read The Skrayling Tree will know, this is not what happens in the book at all. Ulric isn't visited by an albino version of himself (although he and Oona do see White Crow on the island near their home.) Oona isn't abducted at all - Ulric is. The Skrayling Oak isn't used to track anyone - it's the object of the novel's quest. And Gaynor isn't behind the abduction - the Kakatanawa indians are.

The RPG book otherwise summarises the Elric saga so well that these disparities really stood out as rather odd, so I figured I'd ask what happened. Why does the summary of The Skrayling Tree bear so little resemblance to the actual novel itself?
 
Kamelion said:
***Spoilers for The Skrayling Tree below***


I'm leafing through the Elric RPG and finding it a great product. I do have a question unrelated to the game content, however. The brief summaries of the Elric saga are all pretty good, except for the one covering The Skrayling Tree. It states that "Ulrik von Bek... is visited by a strange albino version of himself and, when Oona is abducted by a group of Native Americans, Ulrik trails them using The Skrayling Oak... Finally the hero discovers that Gaynor the Damned, now ruling over a mob of outcasts, is behind Oona’s abduction."

As anyone who has read The Skrayling Tree will know, this is not what happens in the book at all. Ulric isn't visited by an albino version of himself (although he and Oona do see White Crow on the island near their home.) Oona isn't abducted at all - Ulric is. The Skrayling Oak isn't used to track anyone - it's the object of the novel's quest. And Gaynor isn't behind the abduction - the Kakatanawa indians are.

The RPG book otherwise summarises the Elric saga so well that these disparities really stood out as rather odd, so I figured I'd ask what happened. Why does the summary of The Skrayling Tree bear so little resemblance to the actual novel itself?

Mea Culpa.

I read 'The Skrayling Tree' about 4 years ago, and actually sold my copy shortly after. As the Elic book was being written to a tight deadline, and because I simply couldn't get a fresh copy in time, I had to rely on my memory of the book to complete the summary. I'm old, now, and the memory just isn't what it used to be.

Apologies for the inaccuracy! I usually pride myself on being accurate, but concede failure on this one.

Loz
 
Ah, OK - makes sense. No worries. I was just curious, given that the other summaries were all so accurate. Thanks for the quick reply!
 
Back
Top