swordtart's latest activity

  • S
    swordtart reacted to Vormaerin's post in the thread Traveller 5E with Like Like.
    Fantasy has always been substantially more popular than sci fi. Genre wise, it looks to go 1) Fantasy 2) Horror 3) Sci Fi 4)...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    If we are going to talk about systems that are commercially more significant we need to ignore anything that was in the past but is no...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    Well, I hope it brings more players to the game (and the discussion).
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    If you say so. Sounds like a request for clarification for you to confirm or refute that statement. Clearly we have different ideas of...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    Where did I attack the character, motive, or some other attribute of the person making an argument? Where did I show Bad Faith? Where...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    Thank you for your courtesy in acknowledging the misunderstanding. Not everyone will front up when they realise they have misunderstood...
  • S
    swordtart reacted to Sigtrygg's post in the thread Traveller 5E with Like Like.
    I think the penny has finally dropped as to what you are saying, upon running the numbers I have to conceed that 3d keep 2 and 2d then...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    Go ahead. I'll post my own analysis and we can compare notes. Only if you are adding them together. You never add the 3 dice together...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    No they are the fundamental terms when discussing probabilities. The actual numbers probabilities you get are not in dispute and you...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    Every item in the game is optional. If you apply all optional positives and ignore all optional negatives you will get a different...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    No-one was arguing the probabilities. Anyone who has ever played an RPG game using dice probably knows this (and likely spent hours in...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    I am going to explain why I think there are more than 12 outcomes. When rolling 2d6 in Traveller the identity of the two dice is...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    We have different definitions of outcome. By what criteria? Exceptional on p61 is either rolling 6 more or less than the target. With a...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    You still have 36 outcomes, it's just many of them equate to each other. If you are claiming that it is only the total number that is...
  • S
    swordtart replied to the thread Traveller 5E.
    Yup. RPGs without the P or G (and not much R either to be honest) :)
Show older items
Back
Top