AnotherDilbert's latest activity

  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    No, saying that absence of evidence IS evidence of absence is argumentum ad ignorantiam. From your reference: Absence of evidence...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    Yes, I understand what you say, but I see a bit of apples vs. oranges here. We have several conditions for a functioning jump ship...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread Using High Efficiency Batteries for Jump Drives.
    Could, sure, but it would not be my first assumption. I would await more information.
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    No, not unless they are mutually exclusive. If one rule states a sunhat prevents sunburn, and another rule states that sunscreen...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence. Does it say it collect pi-mesons? Exactly what "exotic particles" does a Collector...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread Using High Efficiency Batteries for Jump Drives.
    Oh, joy, we are debating the definition of words again... https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/contradiction A and not...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    If one source says hydrogen filled jump-bubble, and another says a Collector collects particles, I would infer a Collector collects some...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    Yes, apparently. If one source says A and another not A, I would call that a contradiction. If one source says A and another says B but...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    So what exactly and how much is the Collector collecting. Collecting particles from the solar wind: Is it a particle collector or a...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    Fails to mention, so didn't say, so no contradiction. Do you have hydrogen fuel for the power plant? So can you use a little hydrogen...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    You either need jump fuel or a Collector, that somehow collects "exotic particles", and perhaps a little hydrogen? Marc's article does...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread Using High Efficiency Batteries for Jump Drives.
    It does not say either way, so no contradiction. HG isn't the Core book, it's not a book that not everyone owns let alone references?
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    Where is the contradiction? One source says SOME fuel is expelled. Another source says SOME fuel is burnt. Why can't both be true...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    There is no problem or contradiction if we just need a little hydrogen to fill the bubble. E.g. like T4 FF&S states: Where the...
  • A
    AnotherDilbert replied to the thread How jump works.
    They are all true. They are all incomplete descriptions of the same process.
Show older items
Back
Top